Distinguishing between Elder Abuse Neglect & Professional Negligence

Written by Adam Peck Category: Elder Abuse & Neglect January 26th, 2013 2 min read

The difficulty in distinguishing between “neglect” and “professional negligence” lies in the fact that some health care institutions, such as nursing homes, perform custodial functions and provide professional medical care.

When, for example, a nursing home allows a patient to suffer malnutrition, most defendants appear to argue that this was “professional negligence,” the inability of nursing staff to prescribe or execute a plan of furnishing sufficient nutrition to someone too infirm to attend to that need herself. But such omission is also unquestionably “neglect.

Section 15657 of the California Welfare and Institutions Code provides the way out of this ambiguity: if the neglect is “reckless,” or done with “oppression, fraud or malice,” then the action falls within the scope of section 15657 and as such cannot be considered simply “based on … professional negligence” within the meaning of section 15657.2. of the California Welfare and Institutions Code.

The use of such language in section 15657, and the explicit exclusion of “professional negligence” in section 15657.2, make clear the California Elder Abuse Act’s goal was to provide heightened remedies for, as stated in the legislative history, “acts of egregious abuse” against elder and dependent adults (Sen.3d reading analysis, Sen. Bill No. 679 (1991-1992 Reg. Sess.) as amended Sept. 10, 1991, p. 2), while allowing acts of negligence in the rendition of medical services to elder and dependent adults to be governed by laws specifically applicable to such negligence.

That only these egregious acts were intended to be sanctioned under section 15657 is further underscored by the fact that the statute requires liability to be proved by a heightened “clear and convincing evidence” standard.

– from Steven Peck, Senior Attorney at Peck Law Group

Share it

Questions? Check with Peck Today

Blog Lead Form

Elder Abuse and Neglect in Assisted Living Facilities

Elopement in Nursing Homes

Assisted Living Abuse

Settlement Reached in Assisted Living Facility Death

Assisted Living Abuse and Neglect Attorneys

Written by Adam Peck

Expertise: Personal Injury

Adam J. Peck, ESQ is a principal with Peck Law Group, APC. In 2008, Mr. Adam Peck received his Juris Doctorate from Whittier Law School where he graduated Cum Laude. His practice is primarily dedicated to representing Elders, Dependent Adults, along with their loved ones and family members, who have suffered horrific personal injuries.